On Android and the HTC Hero (From an ex Windows Mobile guy)

August 17th, 2009 | Categories: Android | Tags:

I have been a user of Windows Mobile devices for almost exactly four years getting through both a Dell Axim x50v and a HTC TyTN II along the way.  The TyTN II had been my daily driver (as Julie of The Gadgeteer might say) for just over 18 months and, although it has served me very well in so many ways, I have recently found myself wanting more and have been viewing my friend’s Android phones with envious eyes.

The HTC TyTN II is powered by Windows Mobile 6 and is a true monster of a phone in terms of both sheer physical size and list of features.  When I bought it, it represented state of the art in mobile phone technology and for almost a fortnight I could safely state that I had the best phone money could buy.  It does everything…phone, email, GPS navigation, personal organizer, games, Internet, multimedia, RSS reader, ebook reader, camera, mobile WiFi hotspot…the list just goes on and on.  We have grown to expect such long  feature lists in smartphones these days but way back in 2007 it stood out from the crowd.

HTC TyTN 2

It wasn’t long before I simply couldn’t do without it and, as anyone who knows me well will testify, I carried it everywhere. I spend a lot of time traveling and if I ever found myself without it then I would (sometimes quite literally) feel lost.  So, if it was so good and served me so well, why have I just defected over to Android with my new HTC Hero rather than getting the TyTN II’s more natural successor the HTC Touch Pro 2?

Quite simply – I had gotten bored with Windows Mobile!

In the current mobile operating system marketplace, Windows Mobile is something of a dinosaur.  Sure, it gets the job done but it doesn’t have any passion – in a world of Ferrari’s and Lamborghini’s it’s a VW Golf.  It’ll get you to work every day no problem but it doesn’t get your pulse racing.

No longer did I want something that ‘just worked’ – I wanted something that was fun to use and not made by Apple.

Enter the Hero

Over the last few months some of my friends have been buying Android powered phones – devices such as the HTC G1 and the HTC Magic – and, although they piqued my interest, they were just not good enough for me to take the plunge.  The Hero, on the other hand, was a completely different kettle of fish – it looks GORGEOUS and I had serious gadget lust for it.

HTC Hero

I’ve had it for around 2 weeks now and thought I would share some of my thoughts on both the device itself and the Android operating system that it is based on.  I’m going to assume that you already know the basics about Android and that you’ve heard of the Hero and just jump straight in with some observations and answers to questions put to me by people interested in it.

Is the ‘chin’ a problem?

If you take a look at the side profile of the Hero then you will see that it has what many commentators have referred to as ‘a big chin’

HTC Hero chin

I have been asked several times ‘Do you find the chin a problem?’ and the simple answer is ‘no I don’t.’  In fact I quite like it as it makes the Hero look more like a phone and less like a PDA.  It also provides a convenient space for the standard Android compliment of buttons and trackball.  If HTC had copied the iPhone and gone for the featureless, buttonless blob look then everyone would berate them for copying Apple.  So HTC went for something that looks more distinctive and they get berated for that too – ho hum!

Another HTC Hero owner shares an office with me and we both agree – the chin is fine.  Don’t worry about the chin.

Capacitive Touch Screens and Keyboards

Roughly speaking, there are two different types of touch screen technology used by modern mobile phones – resistive touch screens and capacitive touch screens.  The practical upshot is that resistive touch screens (as used by Windows Mobile and old Palm-OS devices) need a stylus in order to be effective whereas capacitive screens (as used by the iPhone, Palm Pre and Android phones) can be controlled by the lightest touch of my sweaty, fat finger.  It seems that the general consensus among bloggers is that resistive touch screens are old and bad whereas capacitive touch screens are new and good.

I disagree!  I don’t like capacitive touch screens very much – especially when I have to use them to type.  They just seem so imprecise compared to the trusty stylus that came with all of my old touch screen devices.  I find using the on screen keyboard of the Hero an absolute nightmare and cannot get a decent typing speed no matter how hard I try.  It’s not just the Hero’s fault though – I have used the HTC G1, Magic and Apple iPhone and I hate their onscreen keyboards as well.

My old HTC TyTN II came with a hardware keyboard and I never used it because I got along with its onscreen keyboard just fine.  I really wish I had a hardware keyboard with the Hero though.

I want my stylus back and while we are at it get off my lawn!

On performance issues and task managers

I’ve read quite a few reviews of the Hero and some of them comment on the fact that it can get a bit sluggish at times.  They’ll say something like ‘I was playing an mp3 while browsing the web and the phone was updating my email, twitter, facebook, RSS feeds, weather and Google latitude position in the background when all of a sudden it felt a bit sluggish’

No s**t sherlock!

Not only is Android a multitasking operating system but the Hero comes with 7 different home screens for you to put your resource-hungry widgets on.  It is all too easy to ask your phone to perform an astonishing number of tasks simultaneously and this tends to slow things down a little.  Expecting otherwise is a little optimistic (to put it politely).

Yes, the Hero can suffer from slowdowns but in my experience it’s generally because you can ask it to do so much.  This isn’t helped by the fact that there seems to be no way of shutting applications down manually – they stay in memory (and often use CPU cycles) until the operating system decides that it’s time for them to go.  The problem is that Android and I have differing opinions on when an application should be shut down.

On my old phone I could press and hold the X icon in the top right hand corner of an application window to kill it (a nice little HTC modification to standard Windows Mobile behavior) but there is no equivalent (that I have found so far) on Android.  So, what you need is a task manager and taskiller does the job nicely – now I can shutdown applications whenever I like.

Some commentators have expressed the view that the Hero should have come with a meatier processor in order to allow it to better deal with the kind of multitasking load that a typical user will throw at it and, of course, I agree – to a point.  We all want faster processors but if HTC had done that then we probably wouldn’t have the Hero today – we’d have it tomorrow.  I’m really glad that we have it today.

I once overheard someone saying (or maybe I read it – I can’t remember) that the Hero had ‘Tomorrow’s software running on today’s hardware.’  Whether or not you think this is a good thing depends on how badly you want to see tomorrow’s software I suppose and I REALLY wanted to see tomorrow’s software.

I, for one, am happy with the result.  As long as you don’t ask it to do too much at once then performance tends to be pretty good (most of the time).  Applications such as Taskiller help with this and I fully expect it to get better with future software updates.

The Marketplace

Finding applications for Windows Mobile can be a wearying experience and I have suffered from all of the following issues at some point or another with my old phone.

  • The website that sells the application you want isn’t compatible with Pocket Internet Explorer so you can’t actually navigate to the application on your phone.
  • You find an app that costs 99 cents for the iPhone and $15.99 for Windows Mobile.  The Windows Mobile version isn’t as good either!
  • You find the app that you want and it is free of charge.  However, you can’t install it over the air – you have to hook it up to your computer and use ActiveSync to install it (admittedly happening less these days).
  • The website that carried the application that everyone raves about has disappeared so you can’t install it.
  • You want to buy the application but you really can’t be bothered to enter all of your personal and credit card details YET AGAIN for YET ANOTHER application provider.

The Android Marketplace solves all of these problems instantly and is a joy to use.  What’s more, it isn’t controlled by some bizarre dictatorship that arbitrarily decides which applications can appear on it and which can’t.  You can also download and install applications from places other than the marketplace if you so wish without illegally jail-breaking your phone .

I like The Marketplace a lot.  It’s not without issues but I’ll talk about those another day – this post is getting too long already.

Sense UI and multi-touch

The Hero is the first device to use HTC’s gorgeous looking Sense UI (an upgrade will be coming out soon for older Android phones it seems). I have to admit – it was videos like the one below that got me hooked on the Hero. It’s just beautiful!

If you have come from the Windows Mobile world then you may have heard of HTC’s TouchFlo 3D and Sense is essentially a development of that software.  Not only is it very pretty but it is also very useful – giving you seven, fully customizable home screens along with full integration with services such as Twitter and Facebook.  You can put all kinds of different things on these home screens ranging from simple application shortcuts, through toggle switches (Wifi on/off for example) to mini-applications called widgets.

The Hero comes with a nice selection of both standard Android widgets and some extra HTC widgets such as a calendar, various clock faces, a photo album, twitter client, music player and Footprints (a geo-tagging widget).  I find that some of the simplest widgets are the most useful such as the messaging widget that allows me to flick through all of my SMS messages as if they were a stack of paper on the screen or the Wifi on/off toggle switch.

Flash Support

The Hero has support for Adobe Flash right out of the box unlike older Android phones and the iPhone (At the time of writing). I haven’t used it much but it seems to work just fine. I’ll write more on this in the future when I have had more experience.

Google Integration

As you might expect, integration with google services such as email and calendar work perfectly.  It’s often simple things that transform the way you use a device and, for me, google calendar is one of them.  I can enter an appointment on my desktop machine and moments later it appears on my phone or vice-versa.  The same goes for adding new contacts.

This might seem like a silly little thing to get excited about but I would say that, because of this integration, I use my phone’s calendar a lot more than I did before I had the Hero and so I am ever so slightly more organised.

Where’s the File Manager?

Back in my Windows Mobile days I used the built in File Manager a LOT. So much in fact that I eventually installed a better alternative called Total Commander.  Android, it seems, doesn’t come with a file manager by default but there are a couple on the market place.  One that I have used a little is called ASTRO (free by the way) but I haven’t used it enough to tell you if I think it’s good or not yet.

3.5mm Headphone Socket

This is another one of those small details that make all the difference…my TyTN II didn’t have a standard headphone socket so I either had to use some special ones  (which I would lose and they seemed to be close to impossible to buy on the high street) or an adapter socket (which I would lose) and so eventually I gave up and stopped listening to music and podcasts on the thing.

I still lose my headphones of course but now I can replace them with any old cheapo pair bought from almost any shop on the high street.  Music, podcasts, YouTube….welcome back into my life.

A rose by any other name…

OK so here’s my secret: I don’t have a HTC Hero. Oh no, what I have is a T-Mobile G2 Touch which is a HTC Hero that has been renamed as a G2 Touch. No other difference…just the name. I have no idea why T-Mobile insist on doing this and I’m having no part in it. When I call T-Mobile I always refer to it as the HTC Hero and they always know what I mean. They don’t even correct me any more.

It must cost T-Mobile money to re brand it in this way and it’s just a waste of time.

Application Recommendations

I’ve found the following fun,useful or both and all of them are available from the Marketplace.  Expect to see a lot more about Android Apps from me in the future.

  • Astro (File Manager – free)
  • DoggCatcher (RSS feed reader and podcast manager -  commercial but worth every penny)
  • Hunt the Wumpus (old, text based game.  Good memories for us old timers. – free)
  • Target (Word game that you’ll have played in many a newspaper – free)
  • TasKiller (Task manager – free)
  • Wikitude (Augmented reality browser – free)

Feel free to tell me of your favourites in the comments section.

Would I recommend it to my wife?

My wife is perfectly happy with most modern technology but she tends to be uncompromising when it comes to functionality and she doesn’t like using any technology for the sake of it. For example, she doesn’t care if she uses Linux or Windows as long as the web browser works and she can access her email. If a colleague sends her a word document and it won’t open in Linux then no amount of jibber-jabber from me will convince her that Linux is the best option because her laptop equipped with Windows and Office will open it just fine.

The same goes for phones. She doesn’t care what operating system her phone runs as long as a) it works as a phone and b) the camera isn’t COMPLETELY crap.

Now, the Hero works just great as a phone UNTIL you try and use it on a (admittedly rare in the UK) bright sunny day. On such a day the screen is completely washed out and you can barely see it which means that you struggle to see what you are dialing because you can’t see the keypad!

Guess what the weather was like when she first asked if she could borrow my phone!

So, onto the camera. The good news is that it’s better than the one on the TyTN II so I am happy BUT (and it’s a big but) the camera on the TyTN II was possibly the worst camera that I have ever had the misfortune to use and so saying the Hero’s one is better is a bit like saying I can ride a unicycle better than a fish.

It’s the usual HTC camera story: slow to focus and actually take a picture, not so good indoors but not too bad outdoors. It’s got 5MP though which is an improvement. The practical upshot is that it’s not as good as the camera on her (much cheaper) dumb-phone (as opposed to smart-phone) and so she is less than impressed with my whizzy new toy.

Finally, we get to boot-up time. Yesterday, we were at a friend’s house for supper and I was asked if I could phone a taxi to take us home at the end of the night. Unfortunately I had switched the Hero off completely to try and stop me from playing with it and so I had to boot it back up. We sat and watched the boot sequence in silence for thirty seconds or so before she said

‘Oh my god that’s crap!’

No…I wouldn’t recommend it to my wife.

Bluetooth problems

Personally, I need Bluetooth for one thing and one thing only – file transfer.  Guess what the Hero’s Bluetooth stack can’t do?  That’s right ladies and gentlemen – you cannot transfer files to and from other devices straight out of the box.  I find this rather quaint to be honest – almost every other phone in existence can do this but my shiny new smartphone can’t.

There is an application that might save me – Bluex – but you need to root your phone in order to use it fully and that’s not something I am prepared to do just yet so I haven’t tried it.

The Verdict

I love the HTC Hero and (capacitive touch screen and Bluetooth issues aside) I am really glad that I moved from Windows Mobile to Android and the HTC Hero. More interesting than Windows Mobile, more open than the iPhone and more apps than Palm Pre it’s the mobile OS of the future and I am glad to be a part of it.

Comments welcomed.

  1. August 17th, 2009 at 19:05
    Reply | Quote | #1

    What about syncing? Is there a nice piece of software that works with windows/mac built-in address book/music player/photolibrary-software/notes…et cetera ?

  2. August 17th, 2009 at 20:18
    Reply | Quote | #2

    Great post mate, should be plenty of food for thought in there for someone who’s thinking of going Android from another smartphone.

    I forgot to mention on my HTC Magic post: I have no 3.5mm jack (so won’t be using it for audio)

    Cheers for the ‘Hunt the Wumpus’ link too – I’m currently reading The Bumper Book of Artificial Intelligence for Boys (or AI – a Modern Approach by Russell and Norvig as it’s more popularly known) and it uses the Wumpus world extensively as an example…

    Cheers!

  3. Mike Croucher
    August 17th, 2009 at 21:21
    Reply | Quote | #3

    @Sander – I have no idea I’m afraid since I didn’t want to sync with my laptop (which runs Linux anyway) so I haven’t looked into it. There may well be a desktop syncing solution but if I were to guess then I would think the best way to do it would be to find software that syncs your local PC/Mac up to your google account and then that would automatically sync with the phone.

    @Paul – The Wumpus app is fun isn’t it? There are a couple of minor cosmetic things that I’d like to see the developer fix/update (the ability to accept lowercase input for example and maybe have a nice retro style green on black text style) but you can’t complain for free.

  4. August 25th, 2009 at 14:01
    Reply | Quote | #4

    Great review Mike. I am still toying with the idea of getting a HTC Hero. Only thing holding me back at the moment is finding the right contract for me and that currently Vodafone won’t let me port my existing number (something they have always let me do before – you think they would welcome the idea as its kind of recycling!)

    I have been weighing up the whole Apple vs Android thing. I like the iPhone but at the same time I don’t like it. Its too wide, feels too fat as a phone. As an iPod great… as a phone… no! The Hero on the other hand is a much nicer design (IMO) and I love the interface and how everything is ‘at the top’ on the surface unlike the iPhone where you did in and out of Apps for things like Googlemail, Facebook, Twitter etc.

    It will prob be a few more weeks/months until I decide but if I can get the right contract for me, the HTC Hero is looking more likely my first choice. With my entire office being Apple iPhone snobs, I look forward to not following the herd!

    Thanks for your review… proved most helpful and informative.

  5. Mike Croucher
    August 25th, 2009 at 14:09
    Reply | Quote | #5

    Glad you enjoyed the review Sharon – thanks for the comment.

    I like the functionality that the iPhone offers but don’t like its philosophy – too much control from Apple IMHO. With Android I feel that the balance is much better and I also like the addition of some actual, physical buttons.

    Apple’s ‘touch only’ paradigm annoys me. I like the buttons (and the trackball) that you get on Adroid phones :)

    Cheers,
    Mike

  6. Neil
    August 28th, 2009 at 10:57
    Reply | Quote | #6

    I have seen some posts on the web saying there are issues in syncing between the phone calendar and google calendar.

    I have read that the problem is when an entry is made on the phone it does not then sync UP with google. But it supposedly works fine when a desktop entry is made, it syncs fine DOWN to the phone.

    Can you report any such issues with this?

    I am about to upgrade from a Blackberry and need the calendar to work in both directions.

    Thanks,
    Neil.

  7. Mike Croucher
    August 28th, 2009 at 12:53
    Reply | Quote | #7

    Hi Neil

    I took a look at the issue you described and my conclusion is that it’s complicated. I had created events on my phone and sure enough they weren’t synced up with google calendar. However, that’s because it turns out that there are several calendars on the phone – a local one called ‘My Calendar’ as well as your google calendar.

    When you add an event you have to ensure that it is being added to your google calendar and not to ‘My calendar’. When I did this it seemed to sync fine but sometimes I end up getting two copies of the event on my online google calendar! Also, deleting something from my phone doesn’t delete it from the online version.

    I have other issues too and I’ll write a detailed blog post on it over the weekend but for now I think that the best way to sum it up is by saying that the implementation is buggy and needs fixing.

    If the calendar is vital to you then I’d hold off on the upgrade if I were you and see how google handle this one.

    Expect a blog post soon,
    Cheers,
    Mike

  8. September 3rd, 2009 at 12:08
    Reply | Quote | #8

    I have been using my HTC hero (Read T-mobile G2) for a about 3 weeks now. It is undoubtebly a great piece of equipment but it does seem to have a couple of quirks that are really frustrating me and seem out of place on such a new smartphone. It is getting so bad I am thinking of putting it on ebay.

    For instance I have just tried to send someone an SMS. I went into messages and selected the converstaion with that person, wrote my message and sent it off. It has delivered that message to an entirley different person in my phone book. Why and how did it do that? Imagine how embarssing that could have been! There wasn’t even a saved converstaion with the accidental recipient. If this happens often I will have no choice but to get rid of it.

    The lack of ability to Sync notes, tasks and calendar with Windows is very annoying. All I have been able to sync with my laptop is my contacts. I have been doing this for the last 3 years wom my last two much older phones. There is no decent syncing suit such as Nokia PC Suite that I had on my E61 and E71. HTC sync just isn’t up to the job. I have resorted to carrying my iPod touch around to do this and am starting to think I would have been better off with an iPhone….

    But on the plus side the hero is solid, easy to use, the android OS is great, the virtual keyboard is fine, even better in Landscap becasue I have fat fingers. Music is fine. It has a headphone jack, battery life is 2 days of average use.

    It does lag a bit but not excessively.

    Soo annoying and so close to perfect – I hope future sofware updates solve the niggles.

  9. Richard
    September 5th, 2009 at 21:03
    Reply | Quote | #9

    Hi Mike,
    I have had my HTC Hero for about 2 wks now & am finding the snyc promblems mentioned by Neil very frustrating. My contacts & calander will copy across from PC to phone but not the other way. Also annoying is the inability to order my contacts surname first (minor point – I’d like to get the sync functioning fully first!). I have contacted both orange (twice) & HTC (three times) but so far to no avail.
    Another issue that I am trying to resolve is the inability to send e-mails from the phone – I can receieve them OK but keep getting an outgoing server refusal when I try & reply.
    The issues above aside the HTC Hero does look & feel a very good phone – but if I can’t get it to carry out the tasks that I want it to then it’s not as good as it should be.
    Thanks,
    Richard

  10. Neil
    September 10th, 2009 at 17:00

    I have read the last few comments and they don’t put me off just yet.

    The issue with the SMS going to the wrong person would be annoying – has anyone else experienced that?

    As for syncing with Windows – PAH – it is a Linux phone.

    Has anyone else had the issue with syncing their calendar with Google Calendar though? That for me is the killer question. If that is going to be a problem then I will have to stick with a Blackberry.

    Cheers,
    Neil.

  11. Mike Croucher
    September 10th, 2009 at 17:14

    Hi Neil

    I have sent hundreds of SMS messages to various people and it hasn’t happened to me yet.

    The google calendar issue seems to have mysteriously stopped! Not sure what I did but no problems with it now. No duplications – everything just seems to work. A fellow Hero owner (in my office) has never had any problems with it at all. Of course, your milage may vary.

    The Hero has issues – that much is for certain – but it is also the best phone I have ever owned by a large margin.

    Cheers,
    Mike

  12. justin
    December 8th, 2009 at 11:24

    Hello, nice article. One thing that might improve your typing experience on the hero is to calibrate the keyboard. It’s in the text input option in the settings menu. It made my typing about 98% accurate, the other 2% is down to my fat fingers.

  13. Mark Green
    March 21st, 2010 at 14:33

    Guess what the Hero’s Bluetooth stack can’t do? That’s right ladies and gentlemen – you cannot transfer files to and from other devices straight out of the box. I find this rather quaint to be honest. Having just got a Hero I asked the same thing about bluetooth to be told. At the end of April ther will be an update for the Hero that will let you transfer files between phones. Very good article by the way thanks.

Comments are closed.